Health

Do Painkillers Work Differently for Men and Women?

Dr. Stacy Livingston

In recent years, the medical community has been delving deeper into how men and women experience pain differently. This exploration has unveiled that not only do pain perceptions vary between sexes, but the effectiveness of pain medications does as well. Understanding these differences is crucial for tailoring effective pain management strategies for everyone.

Biological Variations in Pain Perception

Men and women exhibit distinct physiological responses to pain, influenced by hormonal, genetic, and neurological factors. Research indicates that these differences can affect how pain is processed and, consequently, how medications work.

Hormones play a crucial role in shaping how men and women experience pain. Estrogen and testosterone, in particular, influence pain sensitivity in different ways. Estrogen can either heighten or reduce pain perception depending on its levels and the specific type of pain. Testosterone, on the other hand, has a more consistent pain-dampening effect. This difference in hormonal influence may help explain why men and women often report different levels of pain intensity for the same condition. As Dr. Meera Kirpekar, a clinical assistant professor of anesthesiology at NYU Langone, points out, “Men and women don't have heart attacks the same way, so why would anything else be the same? There are differences in pain signals in the brain and spinal cord.”

Genetics also play a significant role in how individuals experience and manage pain. Certain genes related to pain receptors and inflammation function differently in men and women, leading to variations in pain thresholds and responses to medication. This means that a painkiller that works effectively for one person may not have the same effect for someone else simply due to genetic differences.

Beyond hormones and genetics, men and women appear to rely on different biological systems to regulate pain. A study from the University of California San Diego found that men primarily depend on endogenous opioids—the body’s natural painkillers—to relieve discomfort, while women engage in non-opioid pathways for pain management. This difference suggests that opioid-based medications may not provide the same level of relief for women as they do for men, which could have important implications for how pain treatment is approached.

Implications for Pain Medication Efficacy

The biological differences in pain perception between sexes have significant implications for the effectiveness of pain medications.

Opioid medications don’t work the same way for everyone, and gender differences play a major role in their effectiveness. Research from UC San Diego suggests that women may be less responsive to opioid treatments compared to men, potentially requiring higher doses to achieve the same level of pain relief. This difference likely stems from the fact that men rely more on endogenous opioids—natural painkillers produced by the body—while women engage in alternative pain-relief pathways. These findings highlight the need for a more individualized approach to pain management rather than a one-size-fits-all model.

Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), such as ibuprofen, may also have varying levels of effectiveness between men and women. A 2021 review found mixed evidence but noted cases where ibuprofen reduced pain more efficiently in men. While NSAIDs are commonly used to treat inflammation-related pain, these findings suggest that they may not provide equal relief for both sexes, underscoring the importance of tailoring pain treatment strategies based on biological differences.

Corticosteroids, like prednisone, also appear to affect men and women differently. Studies indicate that women may experience more adverse effects from these medications and may be less likely to increase their dosage due to concerns about side effects. This variability in response further emphasizes the need to consider sex-based differences when prescribing pain management treatments, ensuring that each patient receives the most effective and well-tolerated option.

Personalizing Pain Management Strategies

Recognizing that men and women may respond differently to pain medications is a critical step toward personalized medicine.

A more personalized approach to pain management starts with recognizing that men and women experience pain differently. Healthcare providers must take sex-based physiological differences into account when evaluating pain and prescribing treatments. By doing so, they can ensure that patients receive the most effective and appropriate pain management strategies rather than relying on a one-size-fits-all approach.

For women who may not respond as well to traditional opioid treatments, non-opioid alternatives and integrative therapies offer promising options. Cognitive-behavioral therapy, physical therapy, and acupuncture are just a few of the evidence-based approaches that can help manage pain without the adverse effects associated with some pharmacological treatments. Exploring these options can provide relief while minimizing risks like dependency or unwanted side effects.

The field of pain management is evolving, and ongoing research into sex-specific responses to pain and medications is crucial. Understanding these differences will lead to more precise, tailored treatment plans that improve outcomes for both men and women. As science continues to uncover new insights, the future of pain management will likely move toward more individualized and effective solutions.

Conclusion

Looking ahead, continued research into these differences will be crucial for developing new pain-relief strategies and optimizing existing treatments. As science advances, the future of pain management will likely involve more targeted therapies, better prescribing practices, and an overall improvement in patient care. In the meantime, patients and providers alike can benefit from greater awareness of how these differences impact treatment decisions—because when it comes to managing pain, one size does not fit all.

Sources

Medical News Today

UC San Diego News Center

AAMC News

National Geographic

Dr. Livingston enjoys taking care of patients from the mild to the wild. He is the doctor for you, if you have been to other places and told there was nothing that could be done for your or told “It’s all in your head”. He accepts all types of cases including workers compensation, auto accident and personal injury cases. He believes chiropractic can help everyone add life to their years and get them back to doing what they love.

No items found.
Top
Nth Degree - Safari Dan
Next Up In
Health
Top
Nth Degree - Safari Dan
Mid
Pinnacle Chiropractic (Mid)
Banner for Certainty Tools, Play your Game.  Blue gradient color with CertaintyU Logo
No items found.
Top
Nth Degree - Safari Dan
Mid
Pinnacle Chiropractic (Mid)